Independent analysis of the UK hair & beauty sector
The UK hair and beauty sector deserves honest analysis based on official data, not manufactured crisis narratives designed to drive membership sales and policy lobbying.
Every analysis on this site is backed by government statistics, Freedom of Information responses, and transparent methodology. Challenge our data. Verify our calculations. We welcome scrutiny.
Challenging industry claims with official government data
H&BC claims to be "the only statutory authority" for hairdressers. The 1964 Act creates only a voluntary register with no regulatory powers. Analysis of the Act's provisions shows Section 14 explicitly prohibits the powers H&BC claims to possess.
Industry leaders claim 24% of UK personal bankruptcies come from hair and beauty. The Insolvency Service confirms: this data doesn't exist. Company insolvencies: 1.31%, not 24%. Manual verification shows real figure is 0.15-1.5% maximum.
H&BC claims there will be "no apprenticeships left by 2027." Analysis of DfE data shows this is a projection to zero from a declining trend line, not a forecast. Starts recovered to 6,670 in 2023-24, matching 2019 levels.
H&BC claims employment will fall 93% by 2030. Their own report shows total workforce barely changes (232,700 → 231,000). HMRC data shows 398,000 workers, up 2.1% since 2018. They measured only employee decline while self-employment grows.
CBI Economics claims £2.4bn VAT loss, 93% employment collapse, zero apprenticeships by 2027. Calculation shows £22.7m reality (106x exaggeration). H&BC admits being "integral part of drafting" the report. When challenged, CBI offered phone calls, declined written defense.
Industry lobbyists claim salons pay "3-5 times more tax than retail." Analysis of comparable service businesses reveals salons actually rank 2nd lowest in tax burden. The claim relies on fraudulent comparison between incompatible business models.
Analysis of claims made in Treasury meetings and Parliamentary evidence sessions. Examination of whether statistics presented to government officials match official data sources and whether conflicts of interest were disclosed.
Potential future investigations - subject to time and relevance
Proposed analysis of employment tribunal cases to verify claims about widespread disguised employment. Preliminary review of 450+ cases shows only 2% involved employment status disputes, with minimal successful claims against chair rental.
Proposed analysis of Irish Central Statistics Office data to verify industry claims that VAT cuts saved jobs. Preliminary review suggests employment fell following VAT reductions, contrary to claims made in UK lobbying.